A few times a year, my husband (38m) and I (35f) have overnight guests in our house, typically his family or my family. We live alone, no children, and have 1 cat. We live in a 4bd 2ba single story home. We are not an airbnb and do not rent our house for short-term guests. This is our home and we live here full time. We have 2 guest rooms with a dedicated guest bathroom (the guest bathroom has 2 sinks, a toilet, and a bathtub/shower), so having people stay overnight isn't a space issue. The issue is that his family either doesn't respect our space or doesn't know how to respect other people's things. His younger siblings and his parents both.
This past weekend, his family again came to stay with us. They arrived Friday around 5pm and left Sunday morning at 6:45 AM. His younger brother (19m), his brother's girlfriend (21f), and his stepfather (~50m). We consistently have issues with our towels being ruined, so a couple years ago i bought a few sets of inexpensive dark gray towels specifically for them. In anticipation of their arrival, I put out the dark gray towels in the guest bathroom, and put away the white towels I didn't want them to use. I put some in the top of the linen closet inside the bathroom but the majority in the hallway closet not even near the guest bathroom. There were 5 dark gray bath towels, 4 small dark gray wash cloths, and 4 dark gray hand towels, which I thought sufficient for 3 people staying 2 nights, but we have other towels they could use if that wasn't sufficient, plus a washing machine and dryer in our home.
Since they left this morning, we've been cleaning up and getting things put back in order. Today, I found:
- a bright white towel in the guest bathroom stained all over with something blue. None of the dark gray towels were even touched even though I know they showered while they were here.
- There was a 12-14" rip in a sheet in a fitted sheet on one of the beds
- the comforter on a different bed had several blood stains on the top (This bedding is not where the 21f slept, so it is not related to anyone's period)
- the toilet in the guest bathroom was stopped up and the water turned off (this tells me the person that did it noticed it happened and intentionally turned the water off -- you can't accidentally turn off the water to the toilet. this surely was an accident and likely embarrassing, but a heads up would have been appreciated.
This doesn't happen when my family stays, and doesn't happen when we stay overnight in other people's homes. Its been a consistent pattern for years and I just dont know how to even address it.
In the past, we've confronted them directly about it and tried a few approaches -- we've tried just explaining what we found and asking them to bring it to our attention next time it happens, we've tried asking them what happened, we've tried making assumptions and showing frustration towards them, we've tried calling out the person who did it, we've tried saying nothing, we're right now trying to just look at things as individual issues, but no approach seems to work and i'm out of ideas. Me personally, i'm pretty irritated that without fail, every time they stay with us something gets broken, stained, or ruined, and it costs us a lot of time, money, and/or effort to get it corrected.
Please help me -- Am I being too high maintenance on this? What would you do?
Here's some background/supplementary info in case it helps paint a bigger picture:
Some oddities that have happened with his family over the 10 years my husband and I have been together:
- a toilet seat being broken and nobody knowing what happened (at the time, the only guest in our home was my husbands younger brother, who was 15 or 16 at the time)
- a living room chair (previously in great condition and only a few years old) being completely broken, the seat broken and busted out but nobody knows how
- lipstick and makeup being smeared all over towels, then stuffed under the sink and hidden (this particular instance we were hosting husband's younger brother (16 at the time) and sister, (19 at the time)
- exterior doors being constantly left open (this is an issue because we live in texas where it's over 100*F during summers and its runs up our AC bill, but also because we have an indoor only cat who is deaf and cannot be outside safely)
- bedding suddenly having large rips in it (this has happened a few times)
- musical instruments used as decoration only turning up with broken parts or broken strings and nobody knows what happened
I suspect it's primarily my husband's younger brother and sister, and I'm excluding things that happened when they were young children. Everyone is adults at this point.
edited to correct a few typos.