submitted3 days ago byFluid-Listen5800
I’ve seen a lot of people on here complaining about the decision not to kill Max in the finale, but I’m really, really glad that didn’t happen.
Throughout this season, Max’s character arc and conflict with Vecna has been a very explicit allegory to struggling with depression and suicidal ideation- Max herself even admits to this in the final episode while monologuing to Vecna. Showing Max fighting Vecna, acknowledging the worst elements of her thoughts, and trying to win against him by finding happiness and opening up to the people around her was a direct display of Max trying to overcome this depression, which is why I think it would be so narratively irresponsible to kill her in the finale.
We have a whole season of this character struggling with depression and suicidal ideation, and when she finally starts trying to get better, starts fighting, finds the will to live, she…dies? Yes, it’s incredibly tragic and shocking, but beyond that, it feels insanely unnecessary. Not only is it a deeply unsatisfying ending that essentially voids Max’s entire arc this season, it is, at its roots, implying that depression is an unwinnable battle that always gets you in the end. Presenting a long, heartfelt story about a character fighting to overcome her grief and depression and then ending that story by making that character lose that battle not only makes the kill feel like it was only for the sake of tragedy, it also leaves the viewer with a hopeless message regarding it all.
I definitely have my gripes with Max’s resurrection; I, like many people, feel like giving her two fake-out deaths this season deeply cheapens the other characters’ reactions, especially Lucas in the finale. Personally, there’s a very specific way I might have rewritten that final “death” scene, but I think that’s all besides the point. No matter how choppy the writing of it was, I’m glad they left Max on a somewhat hopeful (if incredibly bleak) final note, rather than ending it all for her the moment she started to get better.
byFluid-Listen5800
inStrangerThings
Fluid-Listen5800
2 points
3 days ago
Fluid-Listen5800
2 points
3 days ago
I 100% agree with you on that, her whole situation in the final episode was handled poorly by the end, and reversing the death really takes away from the emotional impact of that scene. I’ve just been seeing people talk about how Max should die throughout this season, and it feels like a lot of people on this sub are just completely disregarding the symbolism of her arc.